Why You Won't Hear Me Start With Trauma


I'm addressing something difficult today, which might go against the grain. So please get to the end before you decide what you think.

There's a person who I follow and respect on LinkedIn who posts almost daily about trauma. And with every single post they include a picture of the bestselling book The Body Keeps the Score: Brain, Mind, and Body in the Healing of Trauma by Bessel van der Kolk.

The general idea of this book is that it "explores how traumatic stress physically and mentally alters a person, and how the body holds onto the imprint of those experiences". It then recommends multiple ways to recover, using things like somatic practices, EMDR and more.

Bessel van der Kolk is a world renowned expert in PTSD. He's an author, researcher, psychiatrist and educator. I am not remotely qualified to criticize his work.

The person doing the posting on LinkedIn is a coach, like me. Similarly qualified as far as I can see. Probably, I'm sure, a very competent coach.

And so, you might think, this is a useful tool in the armoury of a coach. After all, executive coaching is very closely aligned with psychology. So if we can be "trauma informed" (very fashionable in my world at the moment) we'd be better at our work.

But that is actually a symptom of a very important problem. You see, psychiatry is a very tightly regulated profession. Bessel van der Kolk has to ground his writing, even popular books, in research. Otherwise he risks losing his registration.

Psychology is partially regulated. Anyone can call themselves a psychologist. But not, for example, Clinical Psychologist. Because that title is protected by law. And so most psychologists take great care with their views on their practice.

Coaching, on the other hand, is not a regulated profession at all. Anyone can call themselves a coach whether they have training or not. Whether they are registered with a national body or not. And so, the risk to us saying something wrong, is likely to be minimal.

Trauma is just one example of a word that means something in psychiatry that filters through psychology and into the general population (including coaches). And it has a really damaging impact for a couple of reasons.

Firstly, it does a disservice to people suffering from things like PTSD. And to the practitioners trying to help them. If we all have "trauma", the term starts to become meaningless.

Secondly, what a horrible way to think about the human condition and our own lives. To encourage everyone to mine their past, searching for problems, so that they can focus on their hardships. And then...sell them a solution!

One benefit of the traditional coaching process (and certain, but not all, branches of psychology) is that is is goal oriented. In other words, coaches try to establish where you are now, where you want to go, and what help you need to do to get there.

I know from personal experience, and from countless experiences with clients, that this process focusses the attention on the possible, the desirable and the enjoyable. With that focus properly attuned, people enjoy fulfilment in pursuit of their goals as well as their attainment. Even if they are starting from a difficult beginning.

Whereas, if we start an attempt at self improvement by focusing on trauma, what happens? We see more and more of it because that's the way attention works. And then we risk falling foul of a victim mindset, which is difficult to escape.

In fact, the premise of the book The Body Keeps the Score isn't universally accepted. Which is normal in this field because we're not robots, so different perspectives can be valid. But many neuroscientists would say that trauma is more accurately understood as a "disorder of prediction (where the brain treats neutral bodily feelings as an ongoing threat)" than something genuinely physical.

So where does that leave us?

One suggestion I have is that we approach it philosophically. There are many philosophers who argue that a pursuit of something is the key to human flourishing. Most notably, Viktor Frankly who survived the Holocaust before writing his seminal book Man's Search for Meaning. If he can write this, after everything he experienced, I think the rest of us should listen:

"Everything can be taken from a man but one thing: the last of the human freedoms – to choose one's attitude in any given set of circumstances, to choose one's own way."

Which is why you will never hear me start with trauma, or victimhood or anything similar in my work. I don't want that for myself, my clients or you dear reader.

I want you to imagine a better tomorrow and to pursue it. With all the speed and joy you can muster.

Have a brilliant day, Stephen


I hope it is clear that I am not addressing any criticism towards anyone who has, or is, suffering PTSD or anything similar. Nor am I criticizing brilliant practitioners trying to support them. All the love, S x

--

If you’re curious whether coaching could help you find more clarity or direction, book a free 15-minute Clarity Call and we’ll explore it together.

Or, you can join my HeRO community here.

For anything else, hit reply. I answer every email personally.

Stephen Lock's Newsletter

Weekly writing on decision-making, authority and leading under pressure. For leaders who want thinking, not motivation.

Read more from Stephen Lock's Newsletter

One day, when I had a corporate job, my boss turned to me in a meeting and said, "You would say something like that, wouldn't you. Maverick." It wasn't meant as a compliment. And I was both embarrassed and offended. You see, I have never been someone who wanted to smash the system. My view has always been that we should seek to improve it. I also feel that I am an intrinsic co-creator of any system I am in. And so, blaming others for its shortcomings is lazy and pointless. As the aphorism...

A couple of weeks ago I won a contract to run a workshop. It was a really good match for the kind of work I do. Specifically it was a new version of my "Leading in Complexity" workshop for senior leaders. Get in touch if you want to know more. After we'd agreed the date, one of the people on the call said something interesting. They said they liked my approach because ... hesitation ... trying to find the words ... "You're not woke. Or something like that". That's interesting, I thought. I...

Tonight I am giving my talk on How to Avoid Burnout. If you follow the link and sign up for a free trial, you can come along (and bring friends). As part of the promotion for this, I've created an event on LinkedIn and written a couple of these emails. Nothing particularly dramatic. But there are 63 people who have registered to attend so far. Many of those people have written messages to say "I really need this at the moment" or "this is so timely". Which has taken me by surprise. I'll be...